• Home
• Articles
• Tub vs Shower Remodel: What's Better for Homes in Edmonds & Mukilteo?

Tub vs Shower Remodel: What’s Better for Homes in Edmonds & Mukilteo?

One of the most common decisions homeowners face during a bathroom remodel in Edmonds or Mukilteo is simple but important:

Should you keep the bathtub or convert to a shower?

There isn’t a universal answer. The right choice depends on lifestyle, home value goals, and how buyers in the Edmonds and Mukilteo market actually use bathrooms today.

This guide breaks down functionality, resale value, maintenance, and long-term durability so you can make the right decision before construction begins.

How Homeowners in Edmonds & Mukilteo Are Using Bathrooms Today

In many older homes throughout Edmonds and Mukilteo, bathrooms were designed decades ago when tubs were considered essential. Today, usage patterns have changed.

Most homeowners prefer:

• Larger walk-in showers
• Easier cleaning
• Better accessibility
• Modern appearance

However, removing every tub in a home can negatively impact resale value — especially for families with children.

Walk-In Shower Remodel: Benefits

Daily Functionality

Walk-in showers provide easier entry, more usable space, and improved comfort. For homeowners planning to stay long-term, this is often the most practical upgrade.

Modern Design Appeal

Large tile showers, frameless glass, and linear drains create the updated look buyers expect in remodeled homes across Edmonds and Mukilteo.

Easier Maintenance

Showers eliminate the difficult-to-clean corners and surfaces common in traditional tubs. Proper waterproofing and tile installation also improve long-term durability.

Accessibility

Curbless or low-threshold showers support aging-in-place and future mobility needs.

Bathtub Remodel: Benefits

Resale Expectations

Many buyers still want at least one bathtub in the home, especially families purchasing in residential neighborhoods throughout Edmonds and Mukilteo.

Guest and Secondary Bathrooms

Keeping a tub in secondary bathrooms maintains broader buyer appeal.

Lower Initial Cost

Replacing an existing tub in the same location can sometimes cost less than building a full custom shower system.

Tub-to-Shower Conversion: The Most Popular Choice

In primary bathrooms, tub-to-shower conversions are now one of the most requested remodels.

Homeowners choose this option when:

• The tub is rarely used
• The bathroom feels cramped
• They want a modern appearance
• Maintenance is a concern

A properly built walk-in shower dramatically improves both usability and visual space.

What Adds More Value in Edmonds & Mukilteo?

Real estate trends locally show:

• Primary bathroom: shower preferred
• At least one tub in the home: important for resale
• Updated waterproof tile shower: strong selling feature

The highest value typically comes from balance, not extremes.

Removing the only tub in a home can limit buyers, but keeping unused tubs in every bathroom also reduces functionality.

Construction Considerations Most Homeowners Miss

The decision is not just aesthetic — it’s structural.

Professional installation ensures:

• Correct waterproofing systems
• Proper slope and drainage
• Mold prevention
• Code-compliant plumbing
• Long-term durability

Improper tub or shower installation often leads to hidden water damage years later.

KG Construction focuses on professional preparation and high-quality workmanship so remodeled bathrooms in Edmonds and Mukilteo perform well long after installation.

You can learn more about our bathroom remodeling services in Edmonds through our main service page.

How to Decide: Quick Guide

Choose a Walk-In Shower If:

• It’s your primary bathroom
• You prioritize daily comfort
• You plan to stay long-term
• Accessibility matters

Keep a Tub If:

• It’s the only one in the home
• It’s a kids’ bathroom
• Resale flexibility is important

The Best Approach for Most Homes

For most homes in Edmonds and Mukilteo, the best solution is:

One bathtub + one upgraded shower

This satisfies resale expectations while maximizing daily usability.

Conclusion

Tub vs shower is not about right or wrong — it’s about how the bathroom will actually be used.

Modern homeowners typically benefit most from a well-built walk-in shower, while maintaining at least one tub protects long-term home value.

Making the decision early allows proper planning, permitting, and construction sequencing.

Planning a Bathroom Remodel in Edmonds or Mukilteo?

If you’re deciding between a tub or shower and want professional guidance based on your home and goals, we can help.

Contact KG Construction today to schedule a free on-site estimate and plan a bathroom remodel designed for long-term value and comfort.